Those are both good choices. I wear a green jacket and like it.

It fits very well and I think gives you more freedom of motion than other vests. On the other hand, it's not very floaty for a rescue vest.

There's not a ton of storage space but there's always been enough for my needs. I keep pin kit hardware in the side pockets, tether on the breakaway loop on the front, randoms in the front pocket.

I've jugged a rope on the full strength loop at the bottom. It blew out some stitching holding some foam in place but the loop was bomber. Haven't been vertically extracted in an emergency but would feel good about it after that experience. Then I sent the vest to Astral and they repaired the stitching for free and sent it back to me. Their customer service is awesome.

I like the Kokatat Ronin Pro. It's a low profile vest and I think it has 1 more pound of buoyancy than the Green Jacket.

I'm also a fan of the Kokatat Ronin Pro. Enough storage, lots of flotation, maintains good dexterity and full range of motion. The least restrictive rescue PFD I've used.